The 10 best places to order seafood online

— Recommendations are independently selected by the editors of Gi-Reviewed. Purchases you make through the links below may earn us and our publishing partners a commission.

If you are a seafood lover, you know that seafood is tough. If handled poorly, the taste of the fish will remain. If you want to eat out, it can be expensive. Trying to enjoy fresh seafood at home can also be a challenge, especially if you don’t live near a quality fishmonger or take frequent trips to the beach.

Make smart choices without spending time googling. Subscribe to the Checklist newsletter for expert product advice and recommendations.

That’s where online seafood delivery services come in. They make it easy to get fresh or frozen seafood delivered directly to your door—without that fishy smell. Whether you’re craving high-quality sushi and salmon for a family dinner or looking for tender shrimp and crawfish for that Southern taste, you’ll find it easily with a great online delivery service.

Below, check out the 10 best places to order seafood online and prepare your grocery lists.

1. Many Cows

The 10 best places to order seafood online: Crowd Cow

Crowd Cow has some of the best selections of affordable (and delicious) meats and seafood you can order online. It is a trusted name in food delivery, and its website makes ordering easy. Their Sustainable Seafood section has us writing new things to try. The site also shows a graphic on how to cook the fish.

Crowd Cow has great options from Wild Alaskan Golden King Crab and Icelandic Arctic Char, all for great prices If sustainability is important to you, Crowd Cow does a great job of explaining what that really means. and appearance of fish that is continuous process.

Crowd Cow Shopping

2. Thriving Market

The 10 best places to order seafood online: Thrive Market

Thrive Market is famous for meat but also offers a “Build Your Own Seafood Box” that you can fill with salmon, cod, shrimp, scallops and more. The bundle has seafood savings, which is great for pescatarians and people with a lot of freezer space. Although they don’t have the widest selection, if you already place orders from Thrive Market, ordering your meat and seafood is a great addition without using another subscription.

Shop at Thrive Market

3. Omaha Steak

The 10 best places to order seafood online: Omaha Steaks

Omaha Steaks has over a century of butcher experience and a reputation as “America’s Original Butcher.” Its site is extensive, which is almost a guarantee that they’ll have what you need for your backyard barbecue or fancy fish entrée—including the wine to pair with it. Omaha offers a five-star shrimp dish, split lobster tail skewers and more than a dozen types of fillets, including tilapia, swordfish and grouper. There is a meal for any palette.

It ships anywhere in the United States from its headquarters in Nebraska.

Buy an Omaha Steak

4. Fulton Fish Market

The 10 best places to order seafood online: Fulton Fish Market

If you’re looking for a site completely dedicated to seafood, Fulton Fish Market is it. It offers subscription boxes that you can customize with your favorites like tuna, scallops, shrimp and halibut — and those are the best sellers. The selection is organized by type of fish or shellfish, other seafood entrées (such as caviar, octopus and eel), and bundles.

The bundles are especially worth noting because they offer a variety of favorites that make it easy to host a cookout. Bundles are also an easy way to stock your freezer with family favorites like tuna or cod portions.

Shop at the Fulton Fish Market

5. FreshDirect

The 10 best places to order seafood online: FreshDirect

FreshDirect puts quality over convenience. It has a wide range of groceries selected from food partners and suppliers who are part of a short supply chain, meaning the food is always fresher when it gets to you. Among its offerings, find seafood such as lobster, salmon, clams, shrimp and more. You can choose between fillets, steaks and whole fish.

To make dinner easier, choose from “Prepped Fish” and “Prepped Shellfish,” and check out the “Pairings for Seafood” section to easily find a wine to pair with your meal.

Shop at FreshDirect

6. Giovanni’s Fish Market & Galley

The 10 best places to order seafood online: Giovanni's Fish Market

Giovanni’s Fish Market offers fresh seafood delivered anywhere in the country. Based in Morro Bay, California, it has been operating for over 25 years. It has a wide selection of seafood that varies from crab to oysters to smoked fish and sushi. You’ll also find sauces, soups and spices to make cooking dinner a one-stop-shop (did we mention there’s an extensive page of recipes?).

Once you place your order, everything ships overnight. Giovanni’s has been voted “Best Place to Buy Seafood” by New Time’s “Best of SLO” for the past decade. You can find some of these options on Amazon as well.

Shop at Giovanni’s Fish Market

7. by Rastelli

The 10 best places to order seafood online: Rastelli's

Rastelli’s is a family business that started over 40 years ago as a one room butcher shop. It ships worldwide and adheres to strong values: responsibility, partnership, trust and quality. It is quite transparent and lists its sources for meat, seafood, poultry, pork and even plant-based items. The seafood category is easy to shop, broken down by the most popular items: salmon, flounder, cod, tuna and more.

Rastelli’s seafood options are extensive, ranging from 4-10 filets or steaks. You can order pre-made meals such as grilled salmon with spinach and feta cheese. Yum.

Shop Rastelli’s

8. Important Choices

The 10 best places to order seafood online: Vital Choice

Vital Choice has a monthly subscription box that it calls “a delicious subscription to good health.” It also has meal kits, like the Sockeye Salmon Poke Kit, for a quick and easy dinner option. You can choose to place an order that ships at the same time each month, or choose from a selection of boxes at different price points. You will also find unique items not available on other sites such as wild salmon jerky and calamari.

Shop Vital Choice

9. Sea to Table

The 10 best places to order seafood online: Sea to Table

Sea to Table delivers healthy, delicious and sustainable seafood straight to your door. It has premium selections that are wild caught in the United States. The products are frozen at peak freshness so that when your order arrives you will have a perfect portion for deliciousness. The kits are great and range from the Grill Master’s Kit to the Sweet and Succulent Seafood Set. The kits serve several people—or you can make them for yourself throughout the week.

Shopping Sea to Table

10. Maine Lobster Today

The 10 best places to order seafood online: Maine Lobster Now

Maine Lobster Now is exactly what it sounds like: fresh Maine seafood delivered to your door. Of course, it offers more than just lobster. The current selection includes sea scallops, shellfish, fresh fish, soups and chowders.

Unlike other sites, Maine Lobster Now lets you buy by the portion, the pound or the case, which is great for those of us who cook for one or share freezer space with roommates. It’s also great for large families and anyone hoping to stock up.

If you’re still not sold, the retailer also offers gourmet lobster mac and cheese. You accept. You can find some of these selections on Amazon as well.

Buy Maine Lobster Today

The product experts at examined cover all your shopping needs. Follow Reviewed by Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, TikTok or Flipboard for the latest deals, product reviews and more.

Prices are accurate at the time this article is published but may change over time.

Leave a Comment